Sunday, May 6, 2012

Pratt and Huxley


In her essay “Arts of the Contact Zone,” Mary Louise Pratt discusses the importance of heterogeneity throughout communities. She specifically discusses “the utopian ways modern nations conceive of themselves as what Benedict Anderson calls ‘imagined communities’” (Pratt 525). The modern-day imagining of nations “is strongly utopian” and imagined as “limited,”  “sovereign,” and “fraternal” (Pratt 525). This characterization of modern nations strongly reminded me of the society in Aldous Huxley’s novel Brave New World.
            The most striking similarity to me between the society in Brave New World and Pratt’s characterization of modern nations was the idea of the societies being limited. Pratt further describes limited as “finite, if elastic, boundaries” (Pratt 525). In other words, societies and all their complexity can be controlled and understood. This view of society resonates throughout Brave New World. There are five made up social classes and every embryo is predestined to fit perfectly into one of the social classes. Every part of everyone’s life is controlled and the “community” of the “World State” is essentially a created entity instead of a natural progression of the society itself. The “perfect” community is far from perfect because of how unnatural it is, just as a “limited” society is unnatural. The problem with how modern nations and the World State in Brave New World viewed their societies as limited comes from the fact that societies are not finite. There is no way to define a society and control a society in a natural manner. There is no mathematical formula that can define how a society can be perfectly created and sustained. Much of the abhorrent character of the World State stemmed from the fact that the World Controllers believed they could actually control the world and a utopia would be the result. A dystopia resulted instead because with the focus on a homogenous and controlled world, people were no longer able to grow or transform. The imagined idea modern nations have of themselves was actually obtained by the World State, however, it was repulsive because difference and confrontation were nearly unrecognized.
            There was some difference because of the different social classes, but these differences went unrecognized between the social classes because they were conditioned to not talk to people from other social classes. In “Arts of the Contact Zone,” Pratt discusses a class she taught in which “all the students in the class had the experience, for example, of hearing their culture discussed and objectified in ways that horrified them; all the students saw their roots traced back to legacies of both glory and shame; all the students experienced face-to-face the ignorance and incomprehension, and occasionally the hostility, of others” (Pratt 529). All of these kinds of interaction which resulted in “the most exciting teaching [they] had ever done,” is stripped from the World State’s society and the imagined communities of modern day nations (Pratt 528). So much is lost when difference is ignored and homogeneity throughout society is revered because everyone is different. Society becomes unnatural and interaction becomes meaningless when people believe the world can be reduced to a finite entity in which everyone holds the same beliefs. Huxley and Pratt both recognize the importance of diversity and difference and their regard for these in society is seen throughout both of their writings.

No comments:

Post a Comment