This article is about Joshua Bell, considered one of the
most prolific violin players in the world, playing incognito in a Washington
D.C. subway. The test was to see how many people would recognize the talent of
the violinist, because not only is he one of the world’s most talented
violinists, but he would be playing one of the world’s nicest violins and some
of the most highly regarded compositions, “masterpieces that have endured for
centuries on their brilliance alone, soaring music befitting the grandeur of
cathedrals and concert halls.” He played for 43 minutes with over 1000 people
passing by. The article describes him as playing “with acrobatic enthusiasm,
his body leaning into the music and arching on tiptoes at the high notes. The
sound was nearly symphonic, carrying to all parts of the homely arcade as the
pedestrian traffic filed past.” And during all this, only seven people stopped
what they were doing to listen and watch for at least one minute, and only 27
people gave him money (which amounted to a total of $32.17). Only three days
before Bell appeared at the Metro station, “he had filled the house at Boston's
stately Symphony Hall, where merely pretty good seats went for $100.”
I think Walter Benjamin’s “The Work of Art in the Age of
Mechanical Reproduction” relates to this entire situation. I think it relates in
the sense that art is viewed as “beautiful” to most people only if they are
already told it is beautiful. Although this is not specifically about what
Benjamin discussed with art being mass produced mechanically, Benjamin
describes how “an ancient statue of Venus, for example, stood in a different
traditional context with the Greeks, who made it an object of veneration, than
with the clerics of the Middle Ages, who viewed it as an ominous idol”
(Benjamin 223). The statue of Venus had meaning to these cultures on a local
level. The statue was just not a great piece of art. But in this age where any
piece of art that has meaning to a culture is mass-produced, the meaning of the
art is lost. It is now just viewed as great art because that is what the
critics and everyone else are saying about it. So when Joshua Bell performed at
Boston’s Symphony Hall, people paid hundreds of dollars for tickets because it
has basically been decided that Bell is a great violinist. But when he played
the same music just as enthusiastically incognito, very few people recognize it
as a great performance as they would in a concert hall because they have not
been told he is one of the best violin players and that the music he is playing
is some of the greatest music ever composed. Most people do not even seem to
look for “great art” unless they are expecting it. It is interesting to see how
people are more willing to let someone decide for them what is great art and
what is not as opposed to people deciding for themselves.
No comments:
Post a Comment