In her essay, “Arts of the Contact
Zone,” Mary Louise Pratt speaks of “social spaces where cultures meet, clash,
and grapple with each other, often in contexts of highly asymmetrical relations
of power,” referred to as “contact zones” (Pratt). Pratt criticizes the “imagined
classroom community” (Pratt), which is “described almost entirely from the
point of view of the teacher and teaching, not from the point of view of pupils
and pupiling” (Pratt). Instead, she argues for classroom environments that
recognize all views and interpretations—classrooms that don’t attempt to “unify
the social world” (Pratt). And what unifying the social world means is to
ignore the social, cultural, economical, age, religious, etc. differences
between people. The issue with ignoring these differences is that when they’re
ignored, only one point of view is looked at. This usually is the point of view
of the person/people in charge, whether it is a teacher’s point of view in a
classroom or a conquering nation’s point of view of the “subordinate” nation
they are taking over. The oppressed people are ignored. But their
interpretations are often the most important because they incorporate the
ideologies of the group in charge, as well as their own ideas and beliefs. It
is a comparative view as opposed to the narrow, “rose-colored glasses” view in
which the people in charge frequently profess.
Pratt’s ideas relate to a
controversy about the social studies curriculum revision in the state of Texas
that I recently read about in the article “Texas and the Threat from Within”
written by Michael Bradley. Every ten years, the curriculum of the state of Texas’s
education is revised by an elected state board of education that gets a strong
input on what topics need more/less attention. In this past revision to the
curriculum, many controversial changes were made: The Slave Trade will now be
referred to as the “Atlantic Triangular Trade,” Thomas Jefferson will be almost
entirely absent from the textbooks because of his belief in the separation of
Church and State, the civil rights movement of the 1950’s and 1960’s will be
down-played, capitalism will now be called the “free enterprise system,” Ronald
Reagan’s term in office will be viewed as a “positive, conservative revolution,”
the U.S.
government be referred to as a “constitutional republic” rather than a “democratic
republic,” and these are only some of the changes. And Texas will not be
the only state affected by these changes. Because Texas is such a large consumer,
they control much of the market. The textbooks they purchase will rise to the
top of the market and be cheaper for other states to purchase.
There is a large problem with most
of the nation’s students learning from this type of curriculum, though, and it
is not a conservative versus liberal or a republican versus democratic debate.
The history of our nation is a large part of who we are. We should want our
kids to study our history so they can make the best judgements of what is right
or wrong for our nation based on the positives and negatives of our past. And
to best teach students the history of the United States is to relay it in as
pure and unbiased of a form as it can be. For obvious reasons, it is nearly
impossible to put history into a perfectly unbiased form because whoever is
reporting the history has, to some extent, a biased view of it. But if all the
views (which are likely to be biased) of different groups are accounted for,
then the bias evens out. Texas is attempting to ignore other views and to only
implant one view into their social studies curriculum. So to only say Reagan’s
presidential term was “positive” or to down play the civil rights movement is
wrong. It is wrong because the textbooks ignore the groups who did not think
Reagan’s presidency was positive or who think the civil rights movement is a
critical aspect of the Untied States’ history. And I am not saying Reagan’s
presidential term was negative or the civil rights movement should be a major
focus of social studies classes. Those are debatable. But ignoring groups to
blatantly say which presidential terms were good and bad is simplifying a very
complicated subject. It is ignoring the different people of the United States’
history and their different ideas. It is creating an “imagined community” where
everyone is “engaged in the same game and that game is the same for all players”
(Pratt). To write textbooks in this way is to avoid the “contact zones” that
Pratt emphasizes the importance of. History should be taught through “experiments
in transculturation (‘processes whereby members of subordinated or marginal
groups select and invent from materials transmitted by a dominant or
metropolitan culture’) and collaborative work and in the arts of critique,
parody, and comparison” (Pratt). All aspects that include two or more groups or
cultures being juxtaposed but never just one, single group or culture defining
history. It is okay for there to be biased views taught, just as long as all biased views are taught. But
instead, the Texas State Board of Education is deciding to fill the textbooks
with one, single group’s opinion and skew the history of the United States. But
shouldn’t the students decide if they think Reagan had a positive presidency?
And shouldn’t the students decide if Church and State should be separated, or
at least why our Founding Fathers believed in its ideals? How can such an
important person in our nation’s history be left out like Thomas Jefferson just
because of his beliefs? By jumping to conclusions for the students and ignoring
differing beliefs, contact zones are avoided for the students of these
textbooks.
No comments:
Post a Comment