Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Killing Us Softly


In class, we watched about twenty minutes of Jean Kilbourne’s Killing Us Softly 4. In it, she discusses mainstream advertisements and their negative portrayal of women. She dissects advertisements that attempt to picture the ideal woman, and her issue with this is that these standards are impossible for woman to meet and, more importantly, the advertisements objectify and degrade women. She describes the advertisements like a "toxic cultural environment" that makes it difficult to be culturally healthy just as a toxic physical environment makes it difficult to live healthy. I thought much of what she described was very interesting and I agreed with it as well, but the film also reminded me of something else. In a sociology class I took last year, we were discussing the culture of hip-hop, particularly the culture as it pertains to women. In recitation, my TA for the class told of us a story when he went to school at Morehouse College in Georgia. Spelman College, an all black female school near his college, was going to have Nelly play a fundraiser show on their campus. However, after the release of his video to his song “Tip Drill,” people at Spelman College began protesting Nelly and demanding his show to be cancelled. The reason the students protested was that the video to “Tip Drill” was terribly degrading to women and that its portrayal of women completely contradicted what the college wanted for women. Eventually the protesters won and Nelly’s show was cancelled. After, however, my TA said he attended a discussion of the topic between a music executive, a girl from Spelman, and others. The discussion was supposed to have someone that represented all perspectives on the Nelly controversy, however, my TA said he was disappointed because the one perspective that was not there was of a women who participates in videos like “Tip Drill.” He said the discussion was lacking that perspective and that it would have been more interesting to see one of their perspectives and to understand why they participate in videos like “Tip Drill” and do not see a problem with it.
After watching Killing Us Softly 4, the same thought came to me. Why doesn’t Jean Kilbourne talk to the females that part take in the advertisements that she criticizes as being harmful to women? I have only seen the twenty minutes or so of her video we watched in lecture, so I am not positive that she has not included this in part of her four documentaries, however, I think the perspective of the women that participate in degrading advertisements needs more attention than it receives. Kilbourne and many others have made it very apparent that advertisement companies degrade women in how they portray them in advertisements, and this is important to do in order to cause change. However, the women in these advertisements are participating in something that degrades not only themselves but all women so it would be most interesting if their perspective was analyzed and if they were asked what they think of their actions and whether they see an issue with it or not. Their reason for doing such advertisements may just be for money and a lack of respect for themselves, but they play a central role in all the issues that surround advertisements and I think it is important to understand their perspective.

1 comment:

  1. The problem here is the accusers are abusing the laws. The law is there to ensure the justice for all, while the justice is not enforced in this case. But Plato is give the law its own identity by separating the just and the law, make it more understandable to enforce the law. Because the actions of the accusers are unjustified, it seems odd to have the laws enforced. In this story we have the people pushing Socrates to this position that he must face a death sentence in order to avoid the break of the law. It just seems unreasonable that laws are just blindly enforced even if they are being abused by people who are not using them for justice purposes.
    Confucius said "Therefore, the superior man cultivates a friendly harmony, without being weak.” A superior man stands in the middle firmly. He stands on his own ground without being affected by others. Because he is virtuous and wise, this made him having a better understanding of the world and everything around him. Therefore, he is able to see things clearer than others and has his own opinion about everything. By having his own opinion and thought and having faith in them, he is able to stand in the middle firmly and unaffected. By standing on his ground unaffected, he radiates a firm energy to others, and gain respect from others.

    ReplyDelete